Carmina dupes

Quick take

AI-assisted summary of the notes, prices and community notes listed on this page; no bottle was smelled. How this site is made

None of the three dupes carries a community-consensus basis — all are seller claims of being "inspired by" Carmina, so the field is unranked. On price, ALT. Fragrances' Melodia is cheapest at $0.82/ml (Extrait de Parfum). For the fullest labelling, Oil Perfumery's listing names the original directly — "Impression of Creed - Carmina" — and states its concentration as Perfume Oil, at $1.25/ml. Either is a reasonable starting point. Dua Fragrances' The Poem, a Parfum Extract at $1.62/ml, is the priciest of the three and offers no fuller labelling to justify the gap.

Notes on file exist only for Carmina itself — rose, pink pepper, amber, peony, violet, saffron, black cherry, cashmeran and musk — with no notes on file for any of the three dupes, so how closely each one matches note for note can't be confirmed from this data. The one concrete difference is format: Oil Perfumery is a perfume oil, while the other two are extrait/parfum extract, which changes how the product is applied and worn, though the data holds no performance or longevity claims either way. Beyond the seller's "inspired by" claim, nothing here confirms scent accuracy.