Jo Malone London · 2005 · Woody / ambery (oriental)
Pomegranate Noir dupes
3 products from 3 sources reference Jo Malone London Pomegranate Noir, from $1.10/ml and $16.95 per bottle.
Jo Malone London Pomegranate Noir (2005) is a unisex fragrance in the woody family, ambery (oriental) subfamily. Its listed notes are guaiac wood, lily, cedarwood, amber, incense / olibanum, opoponax and 8 more. Formats on file: extrait de parfum (1), parfum extract (1) and perfume oil (1). Starting prices run from $16.95 to $36 a bottle, or $1.10/ml to $1.33/ml. On file: Punica Noir (Alexandria Fragrances), Oil Perfumery Impression of Jo Malone London - Pomegranate Noir and Apple of Grenada (Dua Fragrances).
Quick take
AI-assisted summary of the notes, prices and community notes listed on this page; no bottle was smelled. How this site is made
With all three dupes listed only as seller claims, the field is unranked here — there's no independent consensus to lean on. On price, Alexandria Fragrances' Punica Noir is the cheapest at $1.1/ml. For the fullest labelling, Oil Perfumery's Impression of Jo Malone London - Pomegranate Noir states format, price and basis in full, which makes it easiest to compare before buying; Dua Fragrances' Apple of Grenada, by contrast, lists no price at all.
No notes are on file for any of the three dupes, so there's no way to confirm which of the original's notes — guaiac wood, lily, cedarwood, amber, incense/olibanum, opoponax, clove, jasmine, musk, patchouli, pink pepper, plum, raspberry, rhubarb — are actually reproduced. Because each dupe's basis is a seller claim rather than a verified comparison, expect the woody-fruity-incense balance to differ to an unknown degree until an independent note breakdown is available.
Every dupe on file
Community clones first, then cheapest per ml. Prices and sizes read from each seller on 4 September 2026. Bar length = price per ml relative to the dearest option; green = cheapest.
| Dupe | Type | Sizes | From | Per ml | Basis | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Punica Noir Alexandria Fragrances | Extrait de Parfum | 10 ml · 30 ml · 55 ml · 60 ml | $19.99 | $1.10/ml | seller claim | View at Alexandria Fragrances |
Oil Perfumery Impression of Jo Malone London - Pomegranate Noir Oil Perfumery | Perfume Oil | 10 ml · 60 ml | $16.95 | $1.33/ml | seller claim · oil | View at Oil Perfumery |
Apple of Grenada Dua Fragrances | Parfum Extract | $36 | n/a | seller claim | View at Dua Fragrances |
How to read this table
A seller claim means the clone house itself published that the product is inspired by Pomegranate Noir. We quote the claim; we have not smelled the bottles. A community pairing means the seller does not name the original and the match comes from reviewer consensus, graded close or moderate.
Price per ml is the honest comparison. Perfume oils look cheap per bottle but come in 10 ml vials; a 100 ml Middle-Eastern EDP at $35 is $0.35/ml and usually the strongest performer in the group. Extraits from clone houses sit in between.
Questions people ask
- What is the best dupe for Pomegranate Noir?
- No community-consensus clone is on file. Among seller-claimed dupes, Alexandria Fragrances Punica Noir is the cheapest per ml at $1.10/ml.
- How much does a Pomegranate Noir dupe cost?
- The cheapest bottle on file is Oil Perfumery Oil Perfumery Impression of Jo Malone London - Pomegranate Noir at $16.95. Per ml, prices run from $1.10/ml upward.
- Do dupes of Pomegranate Noir smell the same?
- No dupe is identical. Seller-claimed clones aim for the same note structure; community clones are rated close or moderate by reviewers. Expect differences in opening, longevity and projection.
Related originals
Jo Malone London
Wood Sage & Sea Salt
7 dupes · from $16.95 · Woody
Clary Sage · Sea Water · Ambrette Seed · Guaiac Wood · Bergamot · Musk
Jo Malone London
Nectarine Blossom & Honey
3 dupes · from $16.95 · Floral
Peach · Blackcurrant Bud · Plum · Mandarin Orange Blossom · Sandalwood · Vetiver
Jo Malone London
Peony & Blush Suede
3 dupes · from $16.95 · Floral
Peony · Suede · Red Apple · Jasmine · Tuberose
Jo Malone London
English Pear & Freesia
3 dupes · from $16.95 · Floral
Pear · Freesia · Bergamot · Patchouli · Rose · Orange Blossom