Carlisle dupes

Quick take

AI-assisted summary of the notes, prices and community notes listed on this page; no bottle was smelled. How this site is made

All three listed dupes for Carlisle are seller claims only, so the field is unranked here — there's no independent consensus to lean on yet. By price per ml, Oil Perfumery's Impression of Parfums de Marly - Carlisle is the cheapest at $1.25/ml and also carries the fullest labelling (explicit reference to the original, format, and price all stated). Dua Fragrances' Cumbria is the next best-documented option at $1.76/ml; its stablemate, Arabian Breed, lists no price, making it harder to weigh against the other two. Starting with the Oil Perfumery gets you the lowest cost per ml with the clearest listing.

Notes on file for Carlisle are opoponax, nutmeg, osmanthus, tonka bean, vanilla, patchouli, rose, and green apple. No note breakdown is on file for any of the three dupes, so nothing here confirms how closely they follow that spice, tonka, and green apple combination. Format differs too: Oil Perfumery is a perfume oil rather than a spray extract like the two Dua options, which will change how it wears and projects, separate from the question of scent accuracy. Treat closeness to the original as unconfirmed until note data is added.